Torino Meatmarket

The General Enthusiasts

Home » Internet hosting Firm Quadranet Asks Courtroom to Dismiss ‘VPN Piracy’ Lawsuit * TorrentFreak

Internet hosting Firm Quadranet Asks Courtroom to Dismiss ‘VPN Piracy’ Lawsuit * TorrentFreak

3 min read

Residence > Lawsuits > Repeat Infringer >


Internet hosting firm Quadranet has requested a Florida federal courtroom to dismiss the “VPN piracy” lawsuit that was filed by a number of unbiased movie corporations. The internet hosting firm argues that it will possibly’t be held accountable for the pirating actions of LiquidVPN subscribers, just because the VPN supplier occurs to lease servers at Quadranet.

A bunch of unbiased movie corporations has taken the piracy legal responsibility difficulty to a brand new degree this 12 months.

After focusing on website house owners and particular person pirates, the makers of movies equivalent to “Hunter Killer”, “I Really feel Fairly” and “Shock and Awe” began going after VPN suppliers. And so they didn’t cease there both.

Over the previous few months, a number of internet hosting corporations have been sued as nicely. The film corporations argue that internet hosting providers will be held liable as a result of they provide their providers to VPN suppliers which, in flip, have pirates amongst their clients.

In response to the film corporations, the internet hosting providers ought to have terminated their agreements with these VPN corporations after repeated copyright infringement warnings. Nevertheless, the internet hosting corporations see themselves as impartial service suppliers, not the Web police.

Quadranet Responds to Piracy Allgetions

Just a few days in the past, Californian internet hosting firm Quadranet replied to the allegations in courtroom. In response to the corporate, the filmmakers’ criticism is a shotgun pleading, and it must be dismissed for that cause alone.

Nevertheless, Quadranet additionally believes that the copyright infringement claims fail. The corporate leased servers to LiquidVPN and did certainly obtain copyright infringement notices, which it forwarded to the VPN service. That must be adequate.

Null-Routing Goes Too Far

The filmmakers prompt that the internet hosting firm ought to have ‘null-routed’ the offending IP-addresses or terminated its service to LiquidVPN, however that goes too far for Quadranet.

“LiquidVPN just isn’t a direct infringer. The one alleged direct infringers are some small portion of LiquidVPN’s buyer base, who apparently utilized LiquidVPN to entry BitTorrent software program.

“Quadranet had no proper to intervene within the relationship between LiquidVPN and its clients, successfully pulling the plug on all of LiquidVPN clients,” the internet hosting firm notes.

At Least Two Steps Eliminated

The internet hosting firm stresses that it’s at the least two steps faraway from any ‘involvement’ within the alleged copyright infringements. Quadranet believes it was dragged into the case for tactical leverage solely, not as a result of there’s a legitimate copyright infringement declare.

Whereas some LiquidVPN clients might have shared pirated content material, that doesn’t imply {that a} internet hosting firm, whivh doesn’t even know who these clients are, must be held liable.

“Underneath the legislation, the act of merely leasing laptop servers just isn’t ‘substantial’ sufficient to be thought of a ‘materials contribution’ to the infringement, very similar to bank card corporations are usually not liable after they merely course of bank card funds to offer entry to infringing web sites,” the corporate argues.

0.00001% of All Income

The accusation that the internet hosting supplier immediately benefited from the infringing actions is refuted as nicely. Not solely does LiquidVPN have many professional clients, however the related income was additionally only a fraction of Quadranet’s earnings.

“Plaintiffs can’t critically counsel in any other case, particularly provided that income from leasing servers to LiquidVPN, for instance, accounted for lower than 0.00001% of Quadranet’s income through the related lease interval.”

Primarily based on these and quite a lot of different arguments, the internet hosting supplier requested the Florida federal courtroom to dismiss the criticism.

Shortly after the authorized paperwork was posted, the courtroom scheduled a mediation listening to, which is able to happen in April subsequent 12 months. This means that the got here might finally be settled in some kind or one other.

A replica of Quadranet’s movement to dismiss will be discovered right here (pdf). The paperwork use QI and QE to discuss with totally different Quadranet entities, we modified these to “Quadranet” within the citations above for the sake of readability